BrickFire Pizza Co.

BrickFire Pizza Co. reviews in Newton. Read guest feedback, 4.4 rating from 426 reviews.

4.4 rating 426 reviews $4 - $21 Newton

1214 Chestnut St 02464-1309

+16174674799

BrickFire Pizza Co. BrickFire Pizza Co. BrickFire Pizza Co. BrickFire Pizza Co.

Topic breakdown

Topics with 10+ reviews.

Food

4.5/5
★★★★★ ★★★★★

175 reviews

Service

4.6/5
★★★★★ ★★★★★

172 reviews

Atmosphere

4.5/5
★★★★★ ★★★★★

169 reviews

Reviews

Recent guest feedback for this restaurant.

Gerry Gan

Apr 3, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Hungry Hutters

Mar 27, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

goated pizza spot

Smart Painting and Carpentry Inc

Mar 27, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

This place if fire it has great pizza

Emmanuel

Mar 27, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Awesome place definitely recommend

Stephen Phillips

Mar 25, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Food was great!! Service was excellent. Cool place!!

Lisa li

Mar 23, 2026 Google_maps
1/5

Pretty sure this was the worst pizza I have ever had. It made Dominos look good. Bad quality marinara sauce, possibly store bought, the trust wasn’t crispy, it was hard. Also I am not sure if they have brick oven as they claim. Horrible taste, horrible vibe. Never coming back

Brittany DeMaria

Mar 22, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

A great place to stop for pizza, Good food and good pizza!

Edinelson Santos

Mar 16, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Ordered Steak and cheese. It was good.

Luke Boyd

Mar 5, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Here’s a softer, more laid-back version: “Really enjoyed my experience at Brickfire Pizza. The staff was friendly and welcoming, the pizza was fresh and flavorful, and the overall atmosphere was relaxed and comfortable. A great local spot to grab a good meal — I’ll definitely be back!”

Paul Buckley

Mar 4, 2026 Google_maps
4/5

BIGMANALFREDO

Feb 27, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Usually im an Alfredo kind of guy but the subs here can't be beat. Me and my son go here regularly and always have a great time. The perfect place to catch up and have a great sub.

TARSHA BAPTISTE

Feb 27, 2026 Google_maps
1/5

I ordered a Lg Turkey BLT. The Turkey was SUPER DRY once I opened my sub it was filled with crumbs of Turkey what happened to sliced.... I've never been so disappointed. I also ordered curly fries and they were cold and soo dry. I do not recommend this place at all

Jv List

Feb 12, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Best pizza place in town

Rich

Feb 7, 2026 Google_maps
1/5

Aliyah Wright

Feb 1, 2026 Google_maps
5/5

Absolutely loved Brick House Pizza! The food was amazing, service was top-tier, and Belal made the experience even better with his great energy and attentiveness. Definitely coming back!

Brian Mc Veigh

Jan 30, 2026 Google_maps
1/5

Used to love this place. I work right around the corner and go 2-3 times a week and get the same exact thing 99% of the time, a chicken ceaser wrap on wheat. Lately I go in and theres always something wrong, they didnt put my order in, I go to pick it up and they say its not ready meanwhile its sitting on the shelf behind them, its always service related with the same guy working the counter. Today I went in 10mins after I had called in my wrap and I was the only customer there and I was there for another 10-15mins before they even started on my order. The guy behind the counter was staring at his phone and the c...

Michael C

Jan 19, 2026 Google_maps
4/5

Good & generous portion of its house Brickfire pizza; Thin crust Italian style. Relatively quick service & decent prices, though a little high, like every other pizza shop. No more paper menus currently. Small shared parking lot outside in a very small strip area near Newton Lower Falls.

Sherry K

Dec 31, 2025 Google_maps
3/5

Paul Pomakis

Dec 12, 2025 Google_maps
3/5

Russell Rivin

Nov 29, 2025 Google_maps
4/5

angie gregory

Nov 22, 2025 Google_maps
5/5

Amazing crust and fresh toppings. We had a chicken bacon ranch and it was outstanding! Quick service and friendly staff.

Sutton

Nov 20, 2025 Google_maps
5/5

I'm in Boston for a birthday trip. Was looking for interesting local spots and this place is right by our hotel. Amazing food- the portions are ENORMOUS and everything is hot and fresh outta the oven. Servers were all super friendly and patient with our out-of-town amazement at the menu. We ordered cinnamon knots and were not expecting 6 GIANT cinnamon rolls to show up- but now we have a sweet treat for a midnight snack!! Definitely keeping this place in my back pocket if/when I come back to Boston!!

Jentel Jordan

Nov 20, 2025 Google_maps
5/5

Excellent Pizza, Wings and Cinnamon knots! We were visiting from out of town and picked this wonderful place because it was close to where we were staying and it was the best choice we made all day! Huge slices of pizza, juicy chicken wings, and I was even able to get a chicken tenderloin to take back to the hotel for my puppy. If you want some real east coast pizza this is the spot. The Cinnamon knots were to due for, we took the other half with us for breakfast. We will definitely be back next time we are in Boston.

See something wrong?

Send a correction for this restaurant and we will review it.

Suggest an edit

BrickFire Pizza Co.

Incorrect data

Status

Sign in

Request access for BrickFire Pizza Co..